The criticism that I read about "The Tipping Point" was by Terry McDermott who works for the Columbia Journalism Review. In this criticism McDermott calls "The Tipping Point" repetitive and says that Gladwell "often over states his case and lacks the rigor to support it." As a reader I would have to agree that although Gladwell does sound as if he is over stating his case but I feel as if it's needed to get his point across because in one chapter he jumps from one idea to another, in order to connect those ideas together so that the reader understands his point he has to restate his case and be repetitive.I also believe that he use valid examples to support his idea of "the tipping point." every example he uses is something that everyone as a reader can relate to or so around them which just straightens his thesis. Overall I think Gladwell does a brilliant job connecting all his ideas and also bring forth many new ideas and examples which we as regular people might not see happening around us.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:fGvQjC6f7ZgJ:www.cjr.org/the_observatory/criticism_of_gladwell_reaches.php+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
No comments:
Post a Comment